5 Amish Recipes With Noodles (2024)

Jump to Recipe

Homemade noodles are a staple among the Amish. They require few ingredients and, really, homemade noodles are not that hard to make. Maybe a little time-consuming. Some Amish are aided by hand-cranked "noodle makers" as opposed to cutting them all out by hand. But there are plenty of Amish cooks who just pick up a knife and cut them out by hand. Hand-made noodles are almost considered an art for among the Amish. So there are many variations on Homemade Noodle Recipes.

Whenever I think about noodles, I'm reminded of an old, funny family story from when I was a child. I was traveling in Italy with my parents and brother, and no one in our family spoke a word of Italian. As I remember the story we were driving around in an area of Italy renown for its green-tinted homemade noodles and, famished, my parents stopped and what they thought was a restaurant. Someone said something to them in Italian and waved us in. We ate what turned out to be super homemade noodles and only found out later, it wasn't a restaurant, it was a convent. Oh well, the noodles were, apparently, super. I don't remember that, I was probably only about 6-years-old.

Scratch-made noodles are an age-old art. Amish moms learn homemade noodle recipes from their moms and then pass the craft down to their daughters who pass it along to theirs and so on. I covered Amish Homemade Noodles history before.... so be sure to check out a more in depth conversation on homemade Amish Noodles.

🍝 Homemade Noodle Ingredients

• 3 eggs
• About 2 cups all-purpose flour
• ½ teaspoon salt

📋 Instructions

1. Beat 3 eggs until frothy.
2. Add flour and stir until of dough texture.
3. Knead until smooth.
4. Turn into floured cutting board.
5. Roll dough, turning often until thin.
6. Let noodle dough dry for 45 minutes.
7. Turn dough and dry ½ hour.
8. Cut into noodles size.
9. Drop into boiling beef or chicken stock, reduce heat and cook at rolling boil about 20 minutes. Season to taste

🍜 Suggested Noodle Recipes

So, what recipes can you use these noodles in? Here are four classics, plus an easy recipe to make your own noodles!

Amish Pizza Casserole

A classic, hearty Amish dish that marries pizza with noodles. Yum.

One Kettle Soup

This is a classic Amish meal that is great to cook up when in a hurry. I've enjoyed this dish numerous times over the years in Amish homes and, to me, it's probably the single dish I identify most with my Amish supper experiences.

This is an old favorite.

See Also

Cauliflower Cheese Soup | Slimming Eats RecipesTRADITIONAL GREEN BEAN CASSEROLE RECIPE FOR CHRISTMAS or THANKSGIVINGBacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts (3 Ingredient Recipe) - Miss in the Kitchen14 Sizzling Winter Soup Recipes to Keep You Warm

Homemade Ravioli Lasagna

🖨️ Full Recipe

More Amish Main Dishes