No Mayo Deviled Eggs (2024)

Published: Nov 2, 2018 · Modified: Jan 31, 2023 by Ashley

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe·5 from 6 reviews

This post may contain affiliate links, which won’t change your price but will share some commission.

This easy to make, classic deviled egg recipe is a bite-sized party appetizer favorite! Perfect for game day, holiday gatherings, and dinner parties. Made with pantry staples - no mayo needed!

It's almost game day, and anyone who really knows me knows that I'm only into any sporting event for one thing only... the food!

And whenever there's an appetizer spread, you better believe I'm gonna make a beeline straight for the platter of deviled eggs!

You can check outmy big game day recipe roundup postfor more game day party favorite recipes!

It's no secret that I love deviled eggs. Well, deviled anything, really.

Growing up, my grandma made deviled eggs that would disappear faster than anything else at every family gathering.

I watched her make them more times than I could count, and she always made a few trays of them in hopes that they would last longer than 10 minutes.

They usually didn't.

She used Miracle Whip in her deviled eggs, and I've done lots of variations over the years.

Most of them used mayonnaise, but lately I've been on a big plain Greek yogurt kick.

I'm partial to using whole milk Greek yogurt - it's rich, creamy, and tangy. It works perfectly here. But feel free to used reduced fat or fat-free if you like.

Another thing that I've changed over the years is the way in which I fill the eggs. I used to mash the filling up with a fork and scoop the filling in with a spoon.

Then I went through the small cookie scoop phase. It was great, and filled the eggs very evenly.

But once I started using this OXO decorating bottle set, it changed everything! It's super easy and makes the eggs lookso pretty!

But I was running into trouble occasionally with some larger chunks of eggs that would get stuck in the tip of the bottle.

And then it struck me - why am I not using the food processor to purée the yolk mixture? DUH.

Ever since that realization, my deviled egg game has been totally on point. The yolks are so smooth and creamy and those swirls are just too pretty!

When it comes to hard boiling the eggs, I'm a total Instant Pot convert.

For large eggs, I cook them for 8 minutes on high pressure, do a quick release, and put them in a bowl of cold water to stop the cooking process.

They turn out perfect every.single.time.

If I'm entertaining at home, I love serving my deviled eggs in myLe Creuset Stoneware Deviled Egg Platter (and it comes in SO many colors!), but if I'm taking them out to a party away from home, I still use my grandma's vintage Tupperware tray.

It makes me smile every single time!

Are you making deviled eggs for game day? What's your favorite way to fill and garnish them?

Still hungry? You may also like...

French-Inspired Deviled Eggs

Dressy Deviled Eggs

Falafel-Spiced Cucumber Bites

Garlicky Goat Cheese + Herb Stuffed Peppadews

📖 Recipe